Proofreading or editing: which one do you need?

In German, three terms are often mixed up: Korrekturlesen, Korrektorat and Lektorat. Knowing which service you need gets you the right quote – and in the end exactly the text you have in mind.

MTR Sprachendienst editorial team Updated Reading time: 4 min

Proofreading: find errors, keep the content

Proofreading focuses on linguistic correctness: spelling, grammar, punctuation and consistent spelling. Content and style stay as they are. It is the right choice when the text is final and only needs to be error-free – for example shortly before printing or submission.

Editing: make the text better

Editing goes further. Besides formal errors it looks at wording, style, clarity and structure: are the sentences clear? Does the tone suit the readers? Are there repetitions or gaps in the argument? The editor makes suggestions; the decision stays with you.

What our proofreading includes

Depending on the order, we check:

  • Spelling
  • Grammar
  • Punctuation
  • Stylistic consistency
  • Formatting
  • Clarity and readability

Tell us whether you want formal corrections only or stylistic suggestions as well – we will tailor the quote accordingly.

Comparison at a glance

ProofreadingEditing
Spelling, grammar, punctuationyesyes
Consistent spelling, formattingyesyes
Style and wordingnoyes
Clarity and structurenoyes
Typical forfinal texts before print or submissiontexts that should become more convincing

How to prepare your text

  • Purpose and readers in one sentence (e.g. application, thesis, website, brochure)
  • Requirements such as citation style, gender-inclusive language or house style
  • Deadline for submission or printing
  • An editable file, e.g. Word – we make changes visible with track changes

Frequently asked questions

Will editing change my content?

No. Editing suggests improvements to style, wording and structure. You decide what to accept.

Do you also check translated texts?

Yes. Translations in particular benefit from a second look at language and style in the target language. Tell us the language when you ask.

How is proofreading charged?

Usually by length and the depth of review you want. Send us the text or a sample – you get a quote in advance.

This guide gives a general overview and is not legal advice. Requirements can differ between authorities and from case to case – if in doubt, check with the office responsible.

Request or appointment?

To schedule an appointment, feel free to call or send us an email. We will get back to you promptly. Thank you in advance!